On 19 November 2026 the world court found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya. It is also a fitting moment to reflect, for the sake of history, on how Bangladesh has received the Rohingya over the decades. In 1978 and 1992, refugees were sent back in conditions now widely questioned. In 2017 the border stayed open, and those it sheltered became the witnesses whose testimony carried the case to The Hague. Bangladesh also helped set the case in motion, hosting the 2018 OIC meeting that inspired it and becoming the largest funder of The Gambia’s legal team. Three exoduses, three answers.

On a cold November morning in The Hague, the President of the International Court of Justice read out a finding the world court had never made before. "The Republic of the Union of Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State." By nine votes to six, after seven years of litigation, a state had been found responsible for the crime of crimes. Across the world, in the camps of Cox's Bazar, people did not have to wait for the news to reach them. That morning, a big screen had been set up to carry the proceedings live, and refugees crowded behind a metal net to watch the judges in the Great Hall of Justice at the Peace Palace. Others followed on televisions and mobile phones, as the words were translated for the crowd. In Kutupalong and Balukhali, in Thangkhali, Hakimpara, Jamtoli and Moynarghona, in Chakmarkul, Unchiprang and Shamlapur, in Leda, Ali Khali, Nayapara and Jadimura, and

out on the island of Bhasan Char, more than a million people heard the world name what had been done to them. Mohammed Osman, whose parents and four siblings were killed by the Myanmar military, said the verdict proved "we were not lying about the genocide." For the Rohingya, this judgment is more than a legal finding. For decades Myanmar has denied that they exist as a people, calling them "Bengalis", illegal migrants in their own land. The world court treated them as what they are, a distinct ethnic group, protected by the Genocide Convention. That affirmation of identity has come from no less a place than the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. And it is a recognition, at last, of a genocide that generations of Rohingya have suffered, from the grandparents who fled in 1978 to the parents who fled in 1992 and the children who fled in 2017. Two laureates It is worth remembering who once…

From the complainant's lawyer to the expert witness, the International Crimes Tribunal's (ICT's) prosecution is riddled with conflicts of interest. These conflicts were brought to its attention but never addressed.

From the complainant's lawyer to the expert witness, the International Crimes Tribunal's (ICT's) prosecution is riddled with conflicts of interest. These conflicts were brought to its attention but never addressed. The International Criminal Court (ICC), which the ICT itself looks to for guidance, disqualified its own Prosecutor on considerably less. On 20 August 2024, a Supreme Court lawyer named Gazi Tamim filed a complaint with the Investigation Agency of the International Crimes Tribunal on behalf of Hefazat-e-Islam leader Mufti Harun Izhar. The complaint named several individuals and accused them of genocide and crimes against humanity in connection with the events of 5 May 2013 at Shapla Chattar. Eighteen days later, on 7 September 2024, a gazette notification appointed Mr Tamim as a Prosecutor of the same Tribunal. He has since helped prosecute the very case that originated from his complaint. There is a Latin principle, nemo iudex in causa sua. In English, it means that no one should be a

judge in their own cause. It began as a rule governing judges, but the principle behind it is wider. Wherever the law gives someone power over another person's fate, it requires them to have no stake in the outcome. Today, we call such a stake a conflict of interest. A prosecutor does not deliver the verdict. They do, however, decide who will stand in the dock, what charges they will face and what evidence the court will see. International criminal law, which governs this case, insists that prosecutors, too, must be impartial and must be seen to be so. The United Nations Guidelines on the Role of Prosecutors (1990) require prosecutors to act impartially and objectively. Without such impartiality, the right to a fair trial guaranteed by Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966) would be meaningless. Before going further, I should disclose where I stand. I act for three of the accused, Dr Dipu…

Every country, not just Bangladesh, needs a space for introspection on certain fundamental matters. These are, for example, power (and its abuse), influence (and its peddling), civil liberties (and its suppression), privacy (and surveillance), probity, integrity, transparency etc. While conscientious journalism serves as a catalyst for advancement, careless ones hinder it, as the latter kind diverts the very agenda of discourse that the media is supposed to engender.

In a Facebook post (Feb 4), my brief take on the much talked about Al Jazeera documentary ("All the Prime Minister's Men") was: "It is something that could have been part of an important conversation, but merely ended up being a cheap sensationalisation of some majorly unsubstantiated claims based on heaps of unrelated information, false insinuations, and deliberately omitted contexts." (Link) You wrote to me, asking what I meant by that. Since this relates to a matter that is now subject of public debate, I thought it would make sense to respond in a public thread. I hope you would not object to such a public nature of engagement. First of all, thank you for your willingness to discuss the AJ piece. I hope this will shed some light on some of the whats, whys, and hows of the documentary that many like me are curious about. I have noted your assessment of the documentary in an interview (Link) where

you attested the claims made in the programme as "well substantiated." So, I decided to watch the documentary for a second time just to be sure that we are referring to the same work, and found myself in agreement with you regarding its "sleek production quality" at least. It indeed gives the feel of watching a "thriller", as you rightly described. With regard to its content, however, I wish I could share your glowing verdict. Regrettably, the artistic liberty the makers took so abundantly in its treatment of "facts/evidence", did not quite make up for the journalistic rigour which the documentary generally lacked. Before elaborating why I found this documentary unsubstantiated, let me make a few things clear. I believe, every country, not just Bangladesh, needs a space for introspection on certain fundamental matters. These are, for example, power (and its abuse), influence (and its peddling), civil liberties (and its suppression), privacy (and surveillance), probity, integrity, transparency etc. While conscientious…

Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.
We do not share your personal details with anyone.